When homeowners start exploring ways to update their bathroom, one option that often comes up is bathtub refinishing. It’s a cost-effective way to make a tired, chipped, or outdated tub look brand new without the high price tag of replacement. But despite its benefits, bathtub refinishing is surrounded by misconceptions that leave many homeowners confused about whether it’s the right choice.
In this post, we’ll clear the air and tackle the most common bathtub refinishing myths—so you’ll know the truth, not the rumors.
Myth #1: Bathtub Refinishing Is Just a Temporary Fix
One of the biggest misconceptions is that refinishing is a “quick patch” that will peel off in months. The truth is, when done professionally, refinishing can last 10–15 years with proper care. The durability depends on the materials, prep work, and skill of the technician.
At Bathtub Made New, we use high-quality coatings and a multi-step process that includes deep cleaning, repairing chips, applying bonding agents, and sealing the finish. This ensures the coating adheres properly and withstands daily use. Proper maintenance—like gentle cleaning and avoiding harsh abrasives—also plays a huge role in extending the life of your refinished tub.
Fact: Refinishing is not a temporary band-aid—it’s a long-lasting, cost-effective alternative to replacement.
Myth #2: Refinishing Looks Cheap Compared to a New Tub
Some homeowners believe a refinished bathtub will look “painted” or “fake.” That might be true with a poor DIY job or low-quality products, but professional refinishing produces a smooth, glossy finish that looks just like a brand-new tub.
In fact, many customers can’t tell the difference between a new tub and a refinished one. Whether your tub is porcelain, fiberglass, acrylic, or cast iron, refinishing restores its original shine and color. You can even change the color of your tub if you’re updating your bathroom’s style.
Fact: A properly refinished tub can transform the look of your bathroom without anyone realizing it’s not brand new.
Myth #3: Refinishing Is Too Expensive—Replacement Is Better
While full bathtub replacement may seem like the “real” solution, the costs add up quickly. A new tub might only cost a few hundred dollars at the store, but installing it requires demolition, plumbing adjustments, and sometimes flooring or wall repairs. By the time the dust settles, replacement can cost anywhere from $3,000 to $10,000 or more.
Bathtub refinishing, on the other hand, costs a fraction of that—typically 70–80% less. You get the look and feel of a new tub without tearing apart your bathroom. For homeowners on a budget or those who simply want a beautiful update without major construction, refinishing is the smarter choice.
Fact: Refinishing saves you thousands while giving you the same fresh, new appearance.
Myth #4: Refinishing Is Just DIY Painting
Some people think refinishing is as simple as rolling on a coat of paint. While there are DIY kits on the market, they don’t compare to professional results. These kits often skip essential steps like acid etching, bonding, and chip repair. The finish is usually uneven, chips easily, and rarely lasts more than a year or two.
Professional refinishing involves specialized equipment, high-grade coatings, and training to ensure a strong bond that looks flawless and resists wear.
Fact: Refinishing is a skilled trade, not a weekend paint project. Leave it to the pros for results that last.
Myth #5: Refinishing Takes Days to Complete
Homeowners often picture their bathroom being out of commission for a week. In reality, professional refinishing can be completed in just one day. Most tubs are ready for use within 24 hours of completion.
This makes refinishing a convenient solution for busy families, rental properties, and anyone who doesn’t want their bathroom torn up for weeks.
Fact: Refinishing is a fast process that minimizes disruption to your daily routine.
Myth #6: Refinishing Doesn’t Work on Old or Damaged Tubs
Think your tub is “too far gone” for refinishing? That’s rarely the case. Professional technicians can repair chips, cracks, stains, rust, and even burns before applying the new finish. Even tubs that look unsalvageable can be brought back to life.
From vintage cast-iron tubs to modern fiberglass units, refinishing is an effective option across a wide range of materials and conditions.
Fact: Refinishing can restore tubs most homeowners assume are beyond saving.
Myth #7: Refinished Tubs Are Unsafe or Give Off Toxic Fumes
Some worry that refinishing involves harsh chemicals that make the bathroom unsafe. While it’s true that refinishing materials require proper handling, professional companies follow strict safety protocols. At Bathtub Made New, we use ventilation systems and industry-approved products to protect your home and family during the process.
Once the finish cures, it’s completely safe and odor-free.
Fact: Professional refinishing is safe when done by trained technicians.
Myth #8: Refinishing Is Only for Bathtubs
Many homeowners don’t realize refinishing can also be applied to sinks, showers, countertops, and tile. If your bathroom surfaces are outdated or damaged, refinishing can provide a fresh, coordinated look throughout the space—without replacement costs.
Fact: Refinishing is a versatile solution for multiple bathroom surfaces, not just tubs.
Myth #9: A Refinished Tub Is Hard to Maintain
Another common misconception is that a refinished tub requires special, complicated cleaning. In reality, maintaining your refinished tub is simple:
-
Use mild, non-abrasive cleaners
-
Avoid harsh chemicals like bleach
-
Rinse after use to prevent soap buildup
-
Don’t use bathmats with suction cups that can damage the surface
Follow these steps, and your refinished tub will stay beautiful for years.
Fact: Refinishing is easy to maintain with basic care.
Why Trust Bathtub Made New?
With so many bathtub refinishing myths floating around, it’s important to work with a company that knows the facts. At Bathtub Made New, we specialize in tub and shower refinishing across Rochester, NY. Our technicians are trained, experienced, and committed to providing top-quality results.
When you choose us, you’re getting:
-
A proven multi-step refinishing process
-
High-quality, durable coatings
-
Fast turnaround (usually in one day)
-
Cost savings compared to replacement
-
A bathroom upgrade that looks brand new
Whether your tub is chipped, discolored, or simply outdated, refinishing is a practical, affordable, and long-lasting solution.
Final Thoughts
Don’t let myths keep you from making the best choice for your bathroom. Refinishing isn’t a quick patch or a second-rate solution—it’s a reliable way to extend the life of your tub and refresh your entire bathroom without breaking the bank.
If you’ve been on the fence because of the common bathtub refinishing myths you’ve heard, now you know the truth. Refinishing is safe, durable, cost-effective, and fast—especially when handled by experienced professionals.
Ready to see the difference for yourself? Contact Bathtub Made New today and let us bring new life to your bathroom.