When planning a bathroom remodel, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is choosing between a bathtub and a walk-in shower. Both options offer unique benefits, but the right choice depends on your lifestyle, your long-term plans, and how you use your bathroom each day. At Bathtub Made New, we help Rochester homeowners compare their options and choose the upgrade that best fits their needs.
Why This Decision Matters More Than You Think
A new tub or shower affects your daily comfort, accessibility, home value, maintenance routine, and budget. Making the right choice now ensures your bathroom supports your lifestyle—not the other way around.
The Case for a Bathtub
A bathtub can be a peaceful retreat and an important feature for certain households. Many families prefer to keep a tub because it’s practical and comfortable.
Benefits of Choosing a Tub
• Great for relaxation and stress relief
• Ideal for households with young kids
• Attractive for future homebuyers
• Many style options including alcove, soaking, and freestanding tubs
When a Tub Makes the Most Sense
A bathtub may be the better fit if you have small children, enjoy soaking, want to maintain resale value, or prefer a spa-like feel in your bathroom.
Maintenance and Upkeep
Tubs require regular cleaning, especially with tile surrounds. If your tub looks worn or outdated, refinishing is a cost-effective solution. Homeowners often choose bathtub refinishing in Rochester, NY to refresh their tub instead of replacing it. If tile is part of your project, tile refinishing services can update the look without demolition.
The Case for a Walk-In Shower
Walk-in showers offer convenience, modern style, and improved functionality, especially for busy households or those planning for long-term accessibility.
Benefits of Choosing a Shower
• Faster, easier daily use
• Better accessibility with low or no threshold
• Makes a small bathroom feel larger
• Modern look that fits any style
• Works beautifully with JETCOAT shower wall systems
• Durable, sleek upgrades with The Onyx Collection shower walls
When a Shower Makes the Most Sense
A walk-in shower is ideal if you rarely take baths, want a more open layout, prefer modern design, or want an easier-to-maintain bathroom.
Tub vs Shower Remodel: What’s Best for Your Home?
The right choice depends on your routine and your bathroom layout.
Think About Who Uses the Bathroom
Consider your daily habits, whether you have children, if anyone has mobility concerns, and how much time you typically spend getting ready.
Evaluate Your Bathroom Size
Small bathrooms often benefit from walk-in showers, while larger layouts may include both. Narrow or awkward layouts may work better with a corner shower or a sleek walk-in design.
Consider Long-Term Plans
If aging in place is a priority, a walk-in shower is typically the safer and more accessible choice. If resale value matters and you currently have no tubs in the home, adding or keeping one bathtub is usually recommended.
Cost Differences: Tub vs Shower Remodel
The cost difference varies based on materials, plumbing adjustments, and installation needs.
Tub Remodel Costs
A bathtub remodel is usually more affordable than converting to a walk-in shower. If your tub is structurally sound, bathtub refinishing services can save thousands compared to a replacement.
Shower Remodel Costs
Walk-in shower remodels cost more due to demolition, waterproofing, and upgraded materials. Many homeowners choose JETCOAT shower wall systems or The Onyx Collection shower walls for a clean look and low-maintenance surface.
Maintenance: Which Is Easier?
Walk-in showers, especially with solid-surface wall systems, are often easier to maintain. Tubs require a bit more scrubbing, especially if used daily. If your tub or tile looks worn, refinishing can make a dramatic difference. Many homeowners update their tile with tile refinishing services to avoid replacement.
Design Options: Which Fits Your Vision?
Both tubs and showers can match your preferred look, from classic to modern.
Tub Design Options
• Freestanding tubs
• Alcove or standard tubs
• Deep soaking tubs
• One-piece tub/shower units
Pairing a refinished tub with freshly refinished tile is a great way to modernize the space without remodeling.
Shower Design Options
• Frameless glass walk-ins
• Curbless showers
• Solid-surface walls like The Onyx Collection shower walls
• Fast-install options like JETCOAT shower wall systems
• Built-in niches and updated fixtures
So… Which Should You Choose?
Choose a bathtub if:
• You enjoy relaxing soaks
• You have children
• You want to maintain resale value
• You prefer a softer, spa-like feel
Choose a walk-in shower if:
• You want convenience
• You prefer a modern, open design
• You’re planning for aging in place
• You want a low-maintenance layout
If you’re still unsure, a professional consultation can help you decide based on your space, goals, and budget.
Ready to Compare Your Options With a Pro?
Whether you’re considering a bathtub refinishing upgrade, a full tub-to-shower conversion, or a modern wall system installation, the team at Bathtub Made New can walk you through every option and help you choose a solution that fits your lifestyle perfectly. Contact us today to get started!