Many Rochester homeowners assume the only way to fix an outdated, chipped, or stained tub is to rip it out and replace it. But here’s the truth: most of the time, replacement is unnecessary, expensive, and disrupts your home far more than you expect. Refinishing, on the other hand, delivers a like-new result without demolition — and without spending thousands more than you need to.
This guide breaks down what homeowners often misunderstand about refinishing vs. replacement, how to know which option is right for your bathroom, and why Bathtub refinishing in Rochester, NY is almost always the smarter investment.
Why Homeowners Immediately Think “Replacement”
When a tub looks worn out, the default assumption is that it must be replaced. But most tubs — even older cast iron or porcelain units — are structurally sound. The issues homeowners notice are almost always surface-level:
-
Discoloration or yellowing
-
Stains that won’t scrub off
-
Minor cracks or spider-cracks
-
Scratches or dullness
-
Peeling, worn, or outdated finishes
These problems make the tub look like a lost cause, but they don’t mean the fixture is beyond saving. In most cases, refinishing restores the surface to a like-new condition for a fraction of the cost of replacing it.
The True Cost of Replacing a Bathtub
Most homeowners only consider the cost of the new tub itself — usually $300 to $800 for a basic model. But the actual cost of replacement is much higher once you factor in everything else:
1. Demolition
Removing an existing tub requires cutting out tile, drywall, and plumbing. There is no such thing as a simple tub swap. Demolition alone often adds $300–$700 to the project.
2. Plumbing Adjustments
Faucet alignment, drain alignment, and water connections rarely match perfectly. A plumber may need to reposition lines, replace valves, or upgrade hardware, which can add $600–$1,200+.
3. Tile or Surround Replacement
Once the walls are opened up, what used to be a “tub replacement” becomes a wall-to-wall tile or surround project. Expect an additional $1,500–$4,000.
4. Disposal & Delivery
Delivering a new tub and disposing of the old one adds another $200–$500.
5. Hidden Surprises Behind the Walls
Mold, rotting studs, damaged subflooring — anything behind the tub can turn a $3,000 job into a $6,000+ job overnight.
When the dust settles, the average bathtub replacement in Rochester costs $4,500–$9,000, even when homeowners started the project thinking they’d only spend a few hundred dollars.
The True Cost of Refinishing
Refinishing skips all the demolition and plumbing work, which is where most of the cost of replacement comes from.
Instead, refinishing:
-
Repairs and smooths the existing surface
-
Removes stains, scratches, pitting, and discoloration
-
Applies a strong bonding agent
-
Adds a new commercial-grade finish
-
Makes the tub look brand new
Average refinishing cost in Rochester: $500–$800.
For most homeowners, the savings alone make refinishing the obvious choice — but the benefits go beyond money.
Why Refinishing Is the Smarter Option (Most of the Time)
1. It Saves Thousands
The price difference is substantial. Even high-end refinishing is still a small fraction of the cost of replacement — and delivers a result 90% of homeowners are thrilled with.
2. Zero Demolition
Your bathroom stays intact.
No mess.
No tearing out tile.
No shutting down the bathroom for weeks.
Most refinishing projects are completed in a single day.
3. The Finish Is Extremely Durable
Modern refinishing products cure into a hard, glossy surface resistant to:
-
Stains
-
Scratches
-
Chemicals
-
Discoloration
-
Everyday wear
A professionally refinished tub typically lasts 10–15 years with proper care.
4. It Works on Almost Any Surface
Homeowners are often surprised to learn that refinishing works beautifully on:
-
Fiberglass tubs
-
Acrylic tubs
-
Porcelain tubs
-
Cast iron tubs
-
One-piece surrounds
If the structure is sound, refinishing is nearly always an option.
5. Perfect for Color Updates
If your bathroom still has almond, beige, bone, or (worst-case) pink/green/blue fixtures, refinishing lets you update the color without replacing the tub.
Bright, clean white is the most popular — and instantly elevates the bathroom.
6. It’s Environmentally Friendly
Replacement sends your existing tub and tile straight to the landfill. Refinishing keeps your bathroom out of the waste stream and reduces manufacturing demand.
7. You Get Faster Results
Replacement timelines can stretch for weeks — waiting for materials, scheduling plumbers, and coordinating the tile contractor.
Refinishing?
You can use your tub again in 24–48 hours.
When Replacement Is the Right Choice
Refinishing is ideal in most situations, but there are cases where replacement is unavoidable.
1. Structural Damage
If the tub is cracked through, leaking, or flexing under weight, surface repair won’t solve the deeper problem.
2. Major Layout Changes
If you’re converting a tub to a walk-in shower, rearranging plumbing, or redesigning the bathroom, replacement is part of the larger plan.
3. Rusted-Through Cast Iron
Surface rust can be handled — but deep, structural rust requires removal.
4. Wrong Size or Poor Fit
If the tub is too small, too shallow, or simply uncomfortable, refinishing won’t change the dimensions.
5. Homeowners Want High-End Premium Upgrades
Some homeowners want a total remodel with smart features, custom stone surrounds, or freestanding tubs. Refinishing can’t turn an alcove tub into a luxury freestanding unit.
The Most Common Myths Homeowners Believe
“Refinishing doesn’t last.”
Incorrect.
Professional refinishing lasts a decade or longer when maintained properly.
“Replacement is cleaner and faster.”
Also incorrect.
Replacement is far messier, creates demolition debris, and often leads to unexpected repairs.
“New tubs always look better.”
Not always. Most replacement tubs in big box stores are thinner, lower-quality acrylic compared to older cast iron or porcelain tubs, which refinish beautifully.
“Refinishing smells terrible.”
Modern refinishing products have low odor, and BMN uses professional ventilation to keep your home comfortable during the process.
“DIY refinishing kits work just as well.”
Not even close.
DIY kits peel within months. Professional refinishing uses industrial-grade coatings and a detailed multi-step process homeowners cannot replicate.
What Refinishing Looks Like (The Process Homeowners Love)
A professional refinishing job from Bathtub Made New includes:
1. Deep Cleaning & Surface Prep
We remove soap scum, mineral deposits, and residues so the new finish adheres properly.
2. Repairs
Chips, cracks, holes, pitting, and worn areas are filled and smoothed.
3. Bonding Agent Application
This chemical bonding process ensures the new coating permanently adheres to the tub.
4. Commercial-Grade Coating
BMN applies multiple layers of coating for a flawless, high-gloss finish.
5. Final Curing
Within 24–48 hours, your tub is ready to use again — looking like it just came out of the showroom.
How to Decide: Refinishing vs. Replacement
Use this quick guide:
Choose Refinishing If:
-
Your tub is structurally sound
-
You want to update the color
-
You’re trying to stay within a budget
-
You want minimal disruption
-
You want a faster solution
-
You have older cast iron or porcelain (refinishes beautifully)
Choose Replacement If:
-
The tub is cracked or leaking
-
You’re doing a full bathroom remodel
-
The layout is changing
-
You want a larger or deeper tub
-
You’re adding luxury features that require a new unit
Why Homeowners in Rochester Choose Bathtub Made New
BMN is the trusted name for Bathtub refinishing in Rochester, NY because:
-
We specialize in refinishing — not general contractors dabbling in tub work
-
We use commercial-grade products designed to last
-
Every technician is trained, certified, and experienced
-
We guarantee a smooth, long-lasting finish
-
Our process saves homeowners thousands
-
We make old bathrooms look modern again
Homeowners often tell us they wish they’d refinished years earlier — especially after seeing how dramatic the results are.
Final Thoughts
Most homeowners drastically underestimate the cost and complexity of replacing a bathtub. Refinishing fixes the same issues — appearance, color, cleanliness — without the demolition, mess, long timelines, or high expense.
If your tub is still structurally solid, refinishing is almost always the smarter choice. If you're ready for a change, contact us today to get started!