When planning a bathroom remodel, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is whether to install a walk-in shower or a bathtub. Both options have their advantages, but the best choice depends on your lifestyle, space, budget, and future needs. At Bathtub Made New, we’ve helped countless Rochester-area homeowners weigh the pros and cons of walk-in showers vs bathtubs, and we’re here to guide you through the decision-making process.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare the benefits, drawbacks, costs, design flexibility, and long-term value of both options so you can make the best choice for your home.
Why This Decision Matters
Bathrooms aren’t just functional spaces—they’re a key part of your home’s comfort, style, and resale value. A tub or shower remodel can completely change how you use the space. Choosing between a walk-in shower and a bathtub isn’t just about aesthetics; it affects:
-
Daily convenience: How quickly you can get ready each day.
-
Safety and accessibility: Important if you’re planning to age in place.
-
Home value: Buyers often have strong preferences.
-
Relaxation vs. efficiency: Whether you prioritize soaking or speed.
The Case for Walk-In Showers
Walk-in showers have surged in popularity over the past decade, especially among homeowners looking for a sleek, modern bathroom design.
Benefits of Walk-In Showers
-
Accessibility and Safety
-
Low or no threshold entry makes them safer for seniors and people with mobility challenges.
-
Ideal for age-in-place bathroom upgrades.
-
Options like grab bars, built-in seating, and slip-resistant flooring make them even safer.
-
-
Space-Saving Design
-
Perfect for small bathrooms where a full tub may feel cramped.
-
Frameless glass enclosures make the space feel larger and more open.
-
-
Modern Style and Customization
-
A wide range of wall systems (such as Onyx and JETCOAT panels) offer beautiful finishes without the hassle of tile grout.
-
Multiple shower head options, niches, and benches can be added.
-
Easy to design around contemporary aesthetics.
-
-
Quick Cleaning and Maintenance
-
Fewer surfaces and less grout compared to bathtubs.
-
Durable wall systems resist mold, mildew, and water damage.
-
-
Resale Appeal for Many Buyers
-
Buyers love modern walk-in showers, especially in master bathrooms.
-
Drawbacks of Walk-In Showers
-
No soaking option: If you enjoy baths, you’ll lose that experience.
-
Resale concerns in family homes: Families with young kids often prefer at least one bathtub in the house.
-
Can be costly: Custom tiled showers are beautiful, but can drive up remodeling costs.
The Case for Bathtubs
Bathtubs remain a timeless feature in many homes, especially for families and those who enjoy unwinding with a soak.
Benefits of Bathtubs
-
Relaxation and Self-Care
-
Soaking in a tub offers stress relief and muscle relaxation.
-
Can be upgraded with jetted or soaking tubs for a spa-like experience.
-
-
Practical for Families
-
Essential for bathing young children.
-
Pets can also be bathed more easily in a tub.
-
-
Resale Value in Family-Oriented Homes
-
Many buyers expect at least one bathtub in the home, particularly in family neighborhoods.
-
-
Design Variety
-
Freestanding tubs, alcove tubs, and corner tubs offer flexible design options.
-
A statement bathtub can serve as the focal point of a luxury bathroom.
-
Drawbacks of Bathtubs
-
Accessibility challenges: Stepping over the high side can be difficult for seniors.
-
Takes more space: Not ideal for small bathrooms.
-
Slower cleaning and more maintenance: Grout, caulking, and tub surfaces require regular care.
-
Water usage: Tubs typically use more water than showers.
Cost Comparison: Walk-In Showers vs Bathtubs
Cost is always an important factor in remodeling.
-
Walk-In Showers: Costs vary based on materials and customization. Prefabricated units are budget-friendly, while custom tiled showers are on the higher end. In Rochester, many homeowners choose Onyx Collection or JETCOAT shower wall systems because they combine style, durability, and lower long-term maintenance.
-
Bathtubs: Standard tubs are generally less expensive to install than a custom shower, but freestanding or jetted tubs can become a major investment.
Pro tip: Refinishing or reglazing your existing tub can be a cost-effective alternative to replacement if you’re not ready for a full remodel.
Space and Layout Considerations
-
Small Bathrooms: Walk-in showers maximize floor space and create an open look.
-
Large Bathrooms: You may not have to choose—many homeowners install both a walk-in shower and a soaking tub in the same space.
-
One-Bathroom Homes: Keep at least one tub for resale value, unless accessibility is your top priority.
Lifestyle Factors to Guide Your Choice
Ask yourself:
-
Do you prefer quick showers or long soaks?
-
Do you plan to stay in your home long-term?
-
Will you be selling soon in a family-oriented market?
-
Do you need accessibility features now—or in the near future?
Resale Value: What Buyers Want
-
Walk-In Showers: Highly desirable in master bathrooms, especially for empty nesters and modern buyers.
-
Bathtubs: Still expected in family homes. Many real estate agents recommend keeping at least one bathtub in the house.
The Best of Both Worlds: Tub-to-Shower Conversions
Many Rochester homeowners choose tub-to-shower conversions as a smart middle ground. This option lets you:
-
Replace an outdated tub with a sleek walk-in shower.
-
Improve accessibility while modernizing the bathroom.
-
Retain a bathtub elsewhere in the home for family needs.
Bathtub Made New specializes in conversions using Onyx Collection and JETCOAT systems, offering durable, stylish, and low-maintenance solutions that look amazing for years to come.
Final Thoughts: Walk-In Showers vs Bathtubs
When it comes to walk-in showers vs bathtubs, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on your space, lifestyle, budget, and long-term plans.
-
Choose a walk-in shower if you want modern style, accessibility, and easy maintenance.
-
Choose a bathtub if you prioritize relaxation, have young children, or want to maximize family resale appeal.
-
Consider a tub-to-shower conversion for the best of both worlds.
At Bathtub Made New, we’ve helped homeowners across Rochester create bathrooms that fit their unique needs. Whether you’re leaning toward a sleek walk-in shower or a timeless bathtub, our team can guide you every step of the way.
Ready to Upgrade Your Bathroom?
If you’re debating walk-in showers vs bathtubs, let Bathtub Made New help you design the perfect solution for your home. Our expert team specializes in:
Contact us today for a free consultation and discover the bathroom you’ve always wanted.