When planning a bathroom remodel, homeowners often face one critical decision — walk-in tub or curbless shower? It’s not just about style. Safety, accessibility, space, and long-term use all come into play. Whether you're aging in place, planning for future mobility needs, or designing a rental that attracts long-term tenants, choosing the right option matters.
So, how do you decide between these two accessible bathing solutions? Let’s break it down so you can make the best choice for your home.
If you’re already thinking about upgrading your bathroom, a remodeling expert can help you find the best option for your space and needs.
What Is a Walk-In Tub?
A walk-in tub is a specially designed bathtub with a watertight door and low step-in threshold, allowing for easier access than traditional tubs. Most come with built-in seating, grab bars, slip-resistant flooring, and even hydrotherapy features.
These tubs are ideal for individuals with limited mobility, seniors, or those who prefer bathing over showering. They're made to promote independence, safety, and comfort — especially during aging in place renovations.
Pros of Walk-In Tubs
-
Safer Bathing Experience: The door-entry design, non-slip surface, and grab bars reduce the risk of slips and falls.
-
Therapeutic Benefits: Some models include jets for hydrotherapy, which can ease joint pain or arthritis.
-
Built for Comfort: Seated bathing offers a relaxing and secure way to soak without lowering yourself to the floor.
Cons of Walk-In Tubs
-
Longer Fill/Drain Times: You typically need to sit inside while it fills or drains, which can be inconvenient.
-
Takes Up More Space: Walk-in tubs require more room than a standard tub or shower pan.
-
Higher Cost: Installation and purchase cost can be significantly more than a traditional bathtub or shower remodel.
What Is a Curbless Shower?
Also known as a barrier-free or low-threshold shower, a curbless shower is flush with the bathroom floor, offering seamless entry without stepping over a ledge. It’s a sleek, modern choice that maximizes space and accessibility.
Curbless showers work well for wheelchair users and anyone wanting a contemporary, open-concept look. They’re also easier to clean and can be customized with grab bars and seating for added safety.
Pros of Curbless Showers
-
Effortless Access: No step makes it ideal for wheelchairs, walkers, and anyone with mobility challenges.
-
Modern Aesthetic: These showers create a spacious, spa-like feel and fit well with modern design trends.
-
Easy to Maintain: With fewer barriers and edges, cleaning is quicker and simpler.
Cons of Curbless Showers
-
Drainage Must Be Precise: The floor must slope correctly to prevent water from flowing outside the shower zone.
-
Water Containment Issues: Without a door or curtain, water can splash into the main floor area.
-
No Soaking Option: If you prefer baths, a curbless shower doesn’t offer that flexibility.
Walk-In Tub vs. Curbless Shower: Key Comparison Points
1. Accessibility and Safety
Both options enhance bathroom safety, but in different ways.
-
Walk-in tubs allow safe seated soaking with minimal stepping.
-
Curbless showers enable easier transfers from wheelchairs or walkers.
If space or mobility is a concern, curbless showers are often more versatile.
2. Maintenance and Cleaning
Curbless showers win here. Their minimal design makes them easier to clean and maintain.
Walk-in tubs require attention to seals, doors, and moving parts, especially over time.
3. Installation and Space
-
Walk-In Tub: May require expanding your bathroom or widening doorways for installation.
-
Curbless Shower: Needs floor modification for proper drainage, which can be more complex.
In smaller bathrooms, a curbless shower might save more space.
4. Cost and Return on Investment
-
Walk-In Tubs: Average between $2,500 and $10,000+ installed, depending on features.
-
Curbless Showers: Generally range from $3,000 to $8,000+ based on tile work and plumbing.
From a resale perspective, curbless showers may appeal more to younger buyers and families, while walk-in tubs can attract aging homeowners or specialized buyers.
5. Lifestyle and Daily Use
Ask yourself:
-
Do I enjoy soaking in a tub regularly?
-
Will I need help getting in or out in the future?
-
Do I prefer a fast shower or a relaxing bath?
If you prioritize a quick routine, go curbless. If you love long soaks, the walk-in tub is your winner.
Which Is Right for You?
Here’s a quick way to decide:
Choose a Walk-In Tub If You:
-
Enjoy soaking and want therapeutic comfort
-
Plan to age in place or accommodate mobility limitations
-
Prefer a seated, enclosed bathing experience
Choose a Curbless Shower If You:
-
Want a sleek, modern look
-
Need wheelchair or walker access
-
Have limited space or want an open, airy layout
Still not sure? Talk to a professional bathroom remodeler who can evaluate your space, needs, and budget to design a solution that works for you — now and in the future.
Final Thoughts
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer in the walk-in tub vs curbless shower debate. Both options provide safe, accessible, and stylish solutions. Your choice depends on your lifestyle, mobility, space, and preferences.
With thoughtful planning and the right remodeler, your bathroom can offer both beauty and function — no matter which direction you choose.
Ready to get started? Contact our team today to explore your options and receive a customized quote for your bathroom remodel.