Walk-In Tubs and Roll-In Showers: Which Option to Choose?

For many homeowners planning a bathroom remodel for aging in place or improved accessibility, choosing between a walk-in tub and a roll-in shower can feel like a major decision. Each option has its own set of features, benefits, and drawbacks—and the best choice often comes down to your personal needs, physical ability, and available space.

In this blog post, we’ll compare walk-in tubs vs roll-in showers to help you make the best choice for your home, lifestyle, and long-term comfort. Whether you’re planning for future mobility changes or caring for a loved one, understanding these two options will set you on the right path toward a safer, more functional bathroom.

What Are Walk-In Tubs and Roll-In Showers?

Both walk-in tubs and roll-in showers are designed to make bathing safer and more accessible. However, their functionality and layout differ significantly.

A walk-in tub features a low threshold door that opens to allow the user to step in and sit on a built-in seat. The tub fills and drains while the user remains seated. These tubs often come with hand-held shower wands, built-in grab bars, and sometimes hydrotherapy jets.

Roll-in showers, on the other hand, are barrier-free shower spaces that allow users to walk or roll directly into the shower area—often without any curb or lip. These showers are ideal for wheelchair users or those who require caregiver assistance.

Walk-In Tubs vs Roll-In Showers: Quick Comparison

Here’s a side-by-side comparison to highlight some of the most important differences:

Feature	Walk-In Tub	Roll-In Shower
Accessibility	Good for those with limited mobility	Best for wheelchair users
Safety Features	Built-in seat, grab bars	Grab bars, no threshold
Water Usage	Higher	Lower
Space Requirements	More compact	Requires more floor space
Installation Complexity	Moderate	Often higher
Daily Use Convenience	Soaking only	Quick and easy
Cost	Moderate to high	Moderate to high

Benefits and Drawbacks of Walk-In Tubs

Advantages of walk-in tubs:

Provide a relaxing soak similar to a traditional tub, but with safer access
Built-in seating reduces the risk of slipping while bathing
Many models offer therapeutic features such as whirlpool jets or heated backrests
Ideal for individuals who enjoy a quiet, spa-like bathing experience

Disadvantages of walk-in tubs:

Must be filled and drained while the user is inside, which can be time-consuming
Not practical for wheelchair users or those who need caregiver assistance
Higher water usage and potentially increased water heating costs
May require upgrading water heater or plumbing

Walk-in tubs are a great option for seniors or people with limited mobility who still enjoy the ritual of soaking in a warm bath and don’t require wheelchair access.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Roll-In Showers

Advantages of roll-in showers:

Completely barrier-free, allowing easy entry for wheelchairs and walkers
Ideal for users who need caregiver support while bathing
Takes up less vertical space, creating an open, modern look
Can be equipped with adjustable showerheads, fold-down seating, and non-slip flooring

Disadvantages of roll-in showers:

Does not offer soaking benefits for those who enjoy baths
May require more extensive waterproofing and slope correction during installation
Open design can lead to water escaping into the bathroom if not properly sloped or sealed

Roll-in showers are the top choice for homeowners who want efficient, accessible showering and prioritize speed, safety, and minimal maintenance.

Which Option Fits Your Bathroom Layout Best?

Your bathroom’s size and layout play a major role in determining whether a walk-in tub or roll-in shower is a better fit.

Small bathrooms: A walk-in tub may be the more space-efficient choice, as it occupies a similar footprint to a traditional tub.
Open floor plans or larger bathrooms: A roll-in shower can be integrated seamlessly, especially with curbless entry and custom tile work.
Drainage considerations: Roll-in showers need careful floor grading to prevent water from pooling or escaping. Walk-in tubs typically don’t have these concerns but may need reinforced floors for support.

Before deciding, measure your space and speak with a remodeling professional to assess how easily each option could be installed in your current setup.

What’s the Cost of a Walk-In Tub vs a Roll-In Shower?

Costs can vary based on model features, labor, and modifications required, but here’s a general breakdown:

Walk-in tubs typically range from $2,500 to $10,000+ installed, depending on features like jets and heated surfaces.
Roll-in showers often cost between $3,000 and $15,000+, especially when major plumbing, tile work, or waterproofing is needed.

You may also need to factor in:

Upgrades to your water heater for high-capacity tubs
Custom tiling or slope corrections for roll-in showers
Grab bar installations, seating, or handheld showerheads

Some accessibility remodeling projects may qualify for tax deductions, rebates, or even Medicare coverage, depending on the medical necessity. Check with a local contractor for an accurate estimate.

Prioritizing Safety: Which Option Offers More Protection?

Both walk-in tubs and roll-in showers offer excellent safety features, and many can be customized further:

Walk-in tubs commonly include:

Anti-slip flooring
Built-in seat
Secure locking door
Easy-to-reach controls
Handheld shower wand

Roll-in showers may feature:

Barrier-free or low-threshold entry
Non-slip floor tiles
Fold-down or built-in seating
ADA-compliant grab bars
Multiple showerhead options

Ultimately, both offer significant safety upgrades compared to traditional tubs or shower-tub combos. The right choice depends on how you bathe and whether you use mobility aids.

Choose Based on Your Daily Routine and Mobility Needs

Ask yourself:

Do I prefer to bathe or shower?
Am I able to step into a tub, or do I need a wheelchair-accessible solution?
Will someone be helping me bathe, such as a caregiver?
Do I want therapeutic benefits like hydrotherapy?
How many people will use this bathroom?

Your answer to these questions can help guide you toward the best solution for your household.

If you or a loved one uses a wheelchair, or if you anticipate future mobility concerns, a roll-in shower is likely the better long-term investment. If you enjoy a good soak and want extra comfort, a walk-in tub may be the ideal addition.

Can You Combine Both? Yes, Here’s How

If you have the space and budget, some homeowners opt for both—a luxurious walk-in tub in the master suite and a roll-in shower in the guest or main bathroom. Others choose a hybrid solution: some modern walk-in tubs come with a shower wand and curtain to offer a standing showering option.

Custom layouts can often accommodate multiple users’ needs, especially in multigenerational households. A professional bathroom remodeler can help you design a solution tailored to your family’s unique routines and space.

Walk-In Tubs vs Roll-In Showers: Final Thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer in the debate of walk-in tubs vs roll-in showers. Both offer significant safety improvements, accessibility benefits, and can enhance your home’s value—especially when designed with aging-in-place in mind.

Your final decision should reflect your current and future mobility needs, daily habits, budget, and space. Whichever you choose, know that upgrading your bathroom for accessibility is one of the smartest investments you can make for long-term comfort and peace of mind.

Ready to Create a Safer Bathroom? We’re Here to Help

At Bathtub Made New, we specialize in bathroom remodeling solutions that combine safety, comfort, and beauty. Whether you're leaning toward a walk-in tub or exploring a roll-in shower, our team can help you design and install the perfect setup for your home.