Why Rochester Homeowners Are Choosing Refinishing Over Replacement

When homeowners start planning bathroom upgrades, one of the biggest decisions they face is whether to replace an old bathtub or refinish it. On the surface, replacement may seem like the obvious solution—after all, why not install something brand new?

But the truth is, replacing a bathtub comes with high costs, messy demolition, and weeks of disruption. That’s why more and more Rochester homeowners are choosing bathtub refinishing over replacement.

In this guide, we’ll break down why refinishing is often the smarter choice, what the process involves, and how it compares to full replacement in cost, durability, and results.

What Is Bathtub Refinishing?

Bathtub refinishing, also called reglazing or resurfacing, is a process where professionals restore the surface of your existing tub. Instead of tearing it out, they repair chips, scratches, and cracks, then apply a durable coating that makes the tub look brand new. The finish is smooth, glossy, and long-lasting, giving your bathroom a fresh upgrade without the hassle of demolition.

At Bathtub Made New, we specialize in refinishing bathtubs, tile surrounds, and showers across the Rochester, NY area. Our proven system brings your bathroom back to life in as little as one day.

Why Choose Bathtub Refinishing Over Replacement?

There are several compelling reasons to go with bathub refinishing instead of a full replacement. Here are the biggest advantages homeowners love:

1. Cost Savings

The number one reason people choose refinishing is simple: it’s much more affordable.

• Replacement costs: A new tub may seem inexpensive at first glance—often just a few hundred dollars at a home improvement store. But the hidden costs add up fast. You’ll need a plumber to disconnect the old tub, haul-away services, new flooring or tile where the old tub sat, and possibly structural adjustments if the new tub doesn’t fit perfectly. Altogether, full bathtub replacement can run $3,000–$7,000 or more.

• Refinishing costs: By contrast, professional refinishing usually costs a fraction of replacement—often 70–80% less. You get a tub that looks like new without draining your remodeling budget.

2. Time Efficiency

Replacing a tub is a major construction project. It can take days or even weeks to complete, especially if additional plumbing or tile work is involved. Refinishing, on the other hand, is fast:

• Most projects are completed in a single day.

• You can usually use your tub again within 24–48 hours.

• No need to rearrange your household routine around a lengthy remodel.

For busy families in Rochester, this quick turnaround makes refinishing the clear winner.

3. Less Mess and Disruption

Tearing out an old bathtub isn’t just expensive—it’s messy. Dust, debris, and demolition noise can disrupt your entire home. With refinishing:

• There’s no demolition.

• The process is contained and controlled.

• You won’t need to replace surrounding walls, flooring, or plumbing.

This is especially helpful for homeowners who want to improve their bathroom without taking on a full renovation.

4. Eco-Friendly Choice

Choosing refinishing over replacement is also better for the environment. Think about it:

• A full replacement means your old tub ends up in a landfill.

• Manufacturing and transporting a new tub requires significant resources.

By refinishing what you already have, you’re reducing waste and making a sustainable choice for your home.

5. Customizable Look

Refinishing isn’t just about fixing what’s broken—it’s also about upgrading your bathroom’s style. With Bathtub Made New, you can:

• Choose from a variety of colors and finishes.

• Match your refinished tub to updated wall systems, such as Onyx Collection or JETCOAT panels.

• Create a fresh, modern look without a full remodel.

This makes refinishing a versatile solution whether you’re updating your forever home or preparing a rental property for new tenants.

The Refinishing Process

If you’ve never seen bathtub refinishing done before, here’s what the process typically looks like:

1. Surface Prep – The technician thoroughly cleans the tub and removes any soap scum, oils, or residue.

2. Repairs – Chips, cracks, and scratches are filled and smoothed.

3. Bonding Agent – A special adhesive coating is applied so the new finish sticks securely.

4. Spray Application – Several layers of high-quality coating are sprayed onto the tub for a smooth, glossy finish.

5. Curing – The tub is left to dry and harden. Within 24–48 hours, your tub is ready to use again.

At Bathtub Made New, our process includes a strong warranty for peace of mind.

Refinishing vs. Replacement: Side-by-Side Comparison

This comparison shows why refinishing has become such a popular choice among Rochester homeowners.

How Long Does a Refinished Tub Last?

A common question we hear is: “Will a refinished tub really last?” The answer is yes. With proper care, a refinished bathtub can last 10–15 years or more. The key is simple maintenance:

• Avoid harsh abrasives or scouring pads.

• Use gentle, non-acidic cleaners.

• Keep drains clear and fix leaks promptly to prevent water damage.

With these easy steps, your refinished tub will stay beautiful for years.

Who Should Consider Refinishing?

Bathtub refinishing is ideal for:

• Homeowners on a budget – Save thousands compared to replacement.

• Rental property owners – Upgrade units quickly between tenants.

• Busy families – Get a refreshed bathroom without weeks of disruption.

• Eco-conscious homeowners – Choose a greener option that avoids waste.

Whether you have a steel, cast iron, or fiberglass tub, refinishing can give you the look of a brand-new bathroom without the headaches of replacement.

Bathtub Made New: Rochester’s Refinishing Experts

At Bathtub Made New, we’ve helped thousands of homeowners across Rochester and the surrounding areas transform their bathrooms through refinishing. Our customers consistently tell us how surprised they are by the dramatic before-and-after results—and how much money they saved by choosing refinishing instead of replacement.

We don’t just stop at bathtubs either. Our team also refinishes tile, shower walls, and vanities, and we offer tub-to-shower conversions, age-in-place bathroom upgrades, and full bathroom remodeling for homeowners looking for even bigger transformations.

Final Thoughts:

So, why choose bathtub refinishing over replacement? Because it’s cost-effective, fast, less disruptive, environmentally friendly, and fully customizable. For most homeowners, it’s the perfect balance of value and results—transforming a worn-out bathroom into a space you’ll love without the stress of full construction.

If your tub looks dull, damaged, or outdated, don’t assume replacement is your only option. Refinishing could give you the bathroom of your dreams—without the nightmare price tag.

Ready to give your bathroom a brand-new look without the hassle of replacement? Contact Bathtub Made New today for a free estimate. Our professional team proudly serves Rochester, NY, and the surrounding communities with expert refinishing and remodeling services.